215 Coney Island Rd, Shelbyville TN 37160
Motivated Seller – Bring all offers! Seller willing to negotiate buyer’s closing costs with strong offer! Enjoy efficiency and low maintenance in this 1.5 year old “like new” treasure in the heart of Shelbyville, TN. Property is not far from Murfreesboro, Lynchburg, and Tullahoma! 3 bedroom/2 full bathrooms built in late 2024 and only 1 owner with no pets. The kitchen appliances stay and seller will negotiate Washer and Dryer if buyer is interested. Home is also approved with Bedford County planning office for an additional 10’x20’ storage building. The property is on City Sewer. Sewer, Water,
CloseDaily local analysis
Facts and context beyond the MLS description
The sections below combine this listing's current facts with locally retained inventory, sale, and location data. They are generated from the same MLS replica that powers the page, without an external data request during your visit.
Current market context
How this property compares in Shelbyville
This property is offered at $268 per square foot, compared with a $208 median for active 3-bedroom homes in Shelbyville. Its asking price falls near the 17th percentile of that active group. The comparison uses 145 active or publicly marketable listings from the same local MLS source, filtered to the same bedroom group rather than mixing every home size together.
The property has been tracked for 0 days, while the current cohort averages 40 days on market. These figures are a point-in-time inventory comparison, not an appraisal or prediction; condition, lot, updates, exact location, and concessions can move an individual sale away from the city-level pattern.
Nearby closed sales
Recent sold homes near this property
The local sold-history cache contains 4 closed sales within approximately 1.25 miles during the last six months. The median recorded sold price in this nearby sample is $160,750, and the median is $105 per square foot where square footage was reported.
Nearby sales are useful context, but they are not automatically comparable: renovation level, acreage, water access, construction quality, financing, and seller concessions can materially change a result. A property-specific valuation should review the most similar homes and the full MLS record before drawing a conclusion.
| Address | Sold | Home | Sold price | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 111 Bethany Ln | Jun 26, 2026 | 3 bd · 1,092 sqft | $140,000 | 0.3 mi |
| 531 E Depot St | Jun 12, 2026 | 3 bd · 1,440 sqft | $117,000 | 0.4 mi |
| 141 Dogwood Ct | May 29, 2026 | 2 bd · 1,150 sqft | $235,000 | 0.6 mi |
| 1111 S Brittain St | May 25, 2026 | 4 bd · 2,512 sqft | $181,500 | 0.7 mi |
MLS timeline
Price and status history
This timeline records the price and public status snapshots received by CloseDaily from the local MLS replica. It is retained separately from the current listing so later changes do not erase the earlier market history. Dates reflect when the source record changed or was first observed by the sync system.
- $274,900 · Active
Location reference points
How this address sits within the Shelbyville area
These distances are precomputed from the listing coordinates and a maintained set of regional landmarks; no mapping service is called when this page loads. Mileage is straight-line distance. Driving minutes are a planning estimate derived from that distance and should be checked against a live route before a showing or commute.
- Downtown Tullahoma15.4 miles straight-line · roughly 28 driving minutes
- Downtown Manchester20.0 miles straight-line · roughly 36 driving minutes
- I-24 at Manchester20.6 miles straight-line · roughly 37 driving minutes
- Arnold Air Force Base21.0 miles straight-line · roughly 38 driving minutes
- Tims Ford Lake21.4 miles straight-line · roughly 38 driving minutes
Continue comparing
Similar active homes in Shelbyville
These active listings are in the same city and a nearby price range. Each link is rendered on the server so visitors and search engines can move between the property, the city inventory, and other relevant homes without returning to a generic search page.
View all Shelbyville homes for sale · See the Shelbyville market report